Which messenger is the most secure
We compare four messengers — WallyMates, Signal, WhatsApp and Telegram — on what actually affects privacy: what is encrypted by default, what the server can see, whether a phone number is required and whether the code can be checked. No "which is best": each makes its own trade-offs, and we say plainly where others are stronger.
What makes a messenger secure
End-to-end encryption by default
Messages are encrypted on your device and decrypted only on the recipient's. It matters that this is on from the start, not a separate "secret" mode that is easy to forget.
Encrypted groups
Many messengers only encrypt one-to-one chats. If you discuss important things in groups, that matters just as much.
Forward secrecy
If a key ever leaks, past messages still cannot be decrypted. This is a property of the Signal protocol (Double Ratchet).
Minimal personal data
Signing up with a phone number ties the account to your identity. Being able to use email means less data about you.
Open source
When the code is published, independent experts can check that the app does exactly what it promises.
Comparison table
Default settings. WallyMates: the current app code; the others: their official materials (links below the table).
| WallyMates | Signal | Telegram | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Private chats | End-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted | Not end-to-end encrypted (only in "Secret Chats") |
| Group chats | End-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted | Not end-to-end encrypted |
| Forward secrecy | No (Static X3DH without Double Ratchet) | Yes | Yes | Only in "Secret Chats" |
| Sign-up | Email or phone number | Phone number | Phone number | Phone number |
| Channels | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Bots | Bot API | No | Business API only | Bot API |
| Web version in the browser | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | No | Clients and server | No | Clients only |
| Platforms | Android, Windows, Web | Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, Linux | Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, Web | Android, iOS, Windows, macOS, Linux, Web |
Sources: Signal — documentation, WhatsApp — security, Telegram — FAQ: secret chats
Each one in brief
Signal
The reference for cryptography: the Signal protocol with forward secrecy, everything encrypted by default, open-source clients and server, run by a non-profit foundation. The price: a phone number is required, and there are no channels, bots or web version.
WallyMates
Private and group chats are end-to-end encrypted from the start, with no switches. You can sign up with email, without a phone number. And it has what Signal lacks: channels with live streams, bots and a web version. Honestly about the weak spots: the protocol has no forward secrecy, the code is closed, and web-version history is protected by a key stored on the server. Details: Security & encryption.
Encrypts private and group chats with the Signal protocol, so message content is well protected. But the app belongs to Meta, requires a phone number and collects metadata: who you talk to and when. WhatsApp Channels are not end-to-end encrypted.
Telegram
The biggest ecosystem of channels, bots and mini-apps. But regular chats and all groups are stored on its servers without end-to-end encryption — that exists only in one-to-one "Secret Chats" on a single device. Full comparison: WallyMates vs Telegram.
What to choose
- You want the strongest message protection and don't mind giving a phone number — Signal.
- You want end-to-end encryption by default, together with channels, bots and a web version, and without a mandatory phone number — WallyMates.
- What matters most is that everyone you know is already there — WhatsApp; messages are protected, but Meta keeps the metadata.
- You need big public channels and bots and privacy comes second — Telegram; use "Secret Chats" for anything personal.
FAQ
Which messenger is the most secure?
In terms of cryptography, Signal is the reference: forward secrecy, everything encrypted by default and open code. WallyMates also encrypts private and group chats by default and lets you sign up without a phone number, but its protocol has no forward secrecy.
Is there a messenger without a phone number?
Yes. WallyMates lets you sign up with email. Signal, WhatsApp and Telegram all require a phone number to register.
Can the WallyMates server read my messages?
Private and group chats are stored on the server encrypted, and the server cannot decrypt them. The exceptions are documented openly: channels are not end-to-end encrypted, and history synced to the web version is protected by a key kept on the server.
How is WallyMates different from Telegram on security?
Telegram has end-to-end encryption only in "Secret Chats", and groups are never encrypted. In WallyMates, private and group chats are encrypted by default.
Is WallyMates available on iPhone?
Not yet: the app is available for Android and Windows, and in the browser.